InstaCuppa vs Mr. Butler Soda Maker: We Compared Both

InstaCuppa vs Mr. Butler Soda Maker: Capsule vs Cylinder - Which Is Right for You?

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only point to products we would suggest to our own family.

What Should You Know Before Choosing Between These Two Soda Makers?

InstaCuppa vs Mr. Butler soda maker comes down to one choice: a capsule bottle or a cylinder machine. InstaCuppa is a Rs 2,199 bottle that uses one small CO2 capsule per litre. Mr. Butler is a Rs 3,300 countertop machine with a refillable steel cylinder. Pick InstaCuppa to carry fizz around, and Mr. Butler for low gas cost at home.

Looking up the Mr. Butler soda maker and weighing other options in India? You've likely noticed there aren't many honest comparisons online.

Most reviews push one product. Or they read like the writer never used either one.

I want to fix that.

Full disclosure: I founded InstaCuppa, so I have a bias. I'll give you the facts and let you decide.

The Mr. Butler Italia and the InstaCuppa Portable Soda Maker take two very different paths to fizzy water at home. Mr. Butler uses a refillable steel CO2 cylinder that sits on your kitchen counter.

InstaCuppa uses single-use CO2 capsules in a portable bottle you can take anywhere. Neither needs power to make fizzy water.

Both work. But they're built for different people with different priorities.

Every spec here comes from each brand's own product page or its Amazon.in listing. We checked them all on 25 October 2026.

Stock check: On 25 October 2026, our soda maker and all three capsule packs showed as sold out on our own store. Mr. Butler's Italia was in stock on its own store and on Amazon.in.

Soda Maker Machine or Portable Soda Maker: What Are You Really Choosing?

A soda maker machine sits on your counter and runs on a big refillable CO2 cylinder. A portable soda maker is a bottle that uses small CO2 capsules. Mr. Butler is the machine, and InstaCuppa is the portable bottle. That one design choice drives every difference in this comparison.

Market size: India's sparkling water market grew 22.53% from 2023 to 2024, says 6Wresearch. It expects a CAGR of 7.2% from 2025 to 2031, to reach USD 14.3 billion by 2031.

Is fizzy water as good for you as plain water? Healthline reports on one study of 13 drinks.

It says: "The study concluded that sparkling water was as hydrating as still water". So the only real question is which way of making it fits your life.

For the full picture, read our complete sparkling water guide for Indian homes.

How Do These Options Compare?

InstaCuppa costs less to start, at Rs 2,199 against Rs 3,300. Mr. Butler costs less to run, since cylinder gas is far cheaper per litre than capsules. InstaCuppa is a hand-held bottle, while Mr. Butler is a 3.8 kg countertop machine. Both need no power and carry a 1-year warranty.

Prices and stock change often. So check both on the day you buy.

What Mr. Butler Does Well

Mr. Butler wins on gas cost, waste and fizz control. One steel cylinder makes 20 to 25 litres, and you swap it when it runs out. You can pick strong, medium or light fizz. It was also in stock on its own store and on Amazon.in when we checked.

I'll start with the competition, because credit is due. Mr. Butler has built a solid product for a clear use.

Gas costs far less per litre: Mr. Butler's cylinder page says: "Keep making soda at just Rs 6 per litre."

It says you can swap an empty cylinder at a nearby stockist "with only a nominal charge for the gas".

No stockist near you? Its mail-in refill page lists Rs 350 for one cylinder, Rs 600 for two and Rs 1,100 for four.

You courier the empty cylinders to Mr. Butler in Kerala, and it sends full ones back. At about 25 litres a cylinder, Rs 350 works out to about Rs 14 a litre, plus your courier cost.

Less waste: One cylinder does the work of about 25 single-use capsules. The cylinder goes back for a refill, not into the bin.

You choose the fizz: Mr. Butler says: "Choose the strength of your fizz: strong, medium or light."

Easy to buy today: On 25 October 2026, the Italia was in stock on Mr. Butler's own store at Rs 3,300. It was also in stock on Amazon.in at Rs 3,399.

A local maker: Its homepage says: "Mr. Butler is the first and only manufacturer of Home Sodamakers in India." Its Amazon.in listing names India as the country of origin.

What InstaCuppa Does Well

InstaCuppa wins on start-up price, size and simple refills. It costs Rs 2,199 with 10 capsules and 2 lids in the box. It is a light bottle that needs no power, so it can go to the office or on a trip. It also comes with a 10-day free trial with free returns.

Now for what our product does differently. For some buyers, it does it better.

Lower start-up cost: At Rs 2,199, InstaCuppa costs about Rs 1,100 less than Mr. Butler's Rs 3,300 store price.

That gap matters if you are not sure you will stick with home soda. You can also see what a portable soda maker costs to run per glass.

Made to carry: Our product page lists it as "Compact & Lightweight". Each capsule fizzes one litre in about 30 seconds, with no power.

No cylinder to swap: You order capsule packs online, and they come to your door. Right now they are sold out, so check stock before you plan around them.

A real trial: Our page lists a "10-Day Free Trial with Free Returns". It also lists a "1 Year Replacement Warranty".

How Much Does It Cost Per Serving?

Per litre, capsules cost Rs 33.30 on our 30-pack, while Mr. Butler gas costs about Rs 6 to Rs 14. So Mr. Butler is cheaper to run at every level of use. The gap grows the more soda you make. InstaCuppa only wins on start-up cost.

What we assumed

• InstaCuppa: Rs 999 for 30 capsules, so Rs 33.30 a litre. The 10-pack is Rs 499, or Rs 49.90 a litre.
• Mr. Butler, stockist swap: Rs 6 a litre, the brand's own figure.
• Mr. Butler, mail-in refill: Rs 350 for a cylinder of about 25 litres, so about Rs 14 a litre, plus courier.
• Start-up: InstaCuppa Rs 2,199 with 10 capsules. Mr. Butler Rs 3,300 with 1 cylinder.

Monthly gas cost at three levels of use

The takeaway: Mr. Butler costs less to run at every level. At 30 litres a month, it saves you about Rs 580 to Rs 820 a month on gas.

At light use, the gap is smaller, about Rs 230 to Rs 330 a month. So ask if a light bottle and a lower start-up price are worth that to you.

For the full math, read our CO2 cylinder vs capsule cost per glass guide.

Portability: There's No Contest

InstaCuppa is a hand-held bottle, so it fits in a bag. Mr. Butler is a countertop machine that weighs 3.8 kg and stands 43.5 cm tall, as listed. Neither needs power. If you want fizz away from home, the bottle is the easier one to carry.

Mr. Butler lists the Italia at 21 x 16.5 x 43.5 cm and 3.8 kg. Its Amazon.in listing gives 3.95 kg.

Its homepage does call the machine "portable & easy", and it needs no power. So you can move it from room to room.

But it is a countertop unit with a steel cylinder inside. InstaCuppa is one bottle with a cap, so it fits a backpack or an office desk.

If you only make soda in your kitchen, weight does not matter much. If you want fizz at work or on a trip, the bottle is easier.

Convenience: Capsule vs Cylinder Refill

With InstaCuppa, you order capsule packs online when they are in stock. With Mr. Butler, you swap the empty cylinder at a stockist or use its mail-in refill. Capsules are simpler to buy. Cylinders are cheaper per litre.

With InstaCuppa: Each capsule holds 8 grams of CO2 and makes one litre. Our capsule page says: "Never attempt to refill used capsules."

Packs come in 10, 20 or 30, at Rs 499, Rs 799 and Rs 999. On 25 October 2026, all three packs showed as sold out on our store.

With Mr. Butler: Use its dealer locator to find a stockist by PIN code. You can set it to show only in-stock shops.

Its page also says: "Call 1800 103 1557 or SMS refill to 8129177779". Its product page lists refill shops in many states, from Andhra Pradesh and Delhi NCR to Kerala and West Bengal.

No shop near you? Its mail-in page says: "Return your empty cylinders and get filled cylinders at your doorstep, at a fraction of the cost."

Mr. Butler also warns: "Beware of locally refilled refills." Our soda maker CO2 refill guide for India covers safe refills in detail.

Neither refill method is better for everyone. Capsules save time, and cylinders save money.

What Should You Know About Who Should Buy Mr. Butler?

Buy Mr. Butler if you drink fizzy water every day at home. It suits families who share one machine and can reach a stockist or wait for a mail-in refill. At high use, its lower gas cost adds up fast.

The Mr. Butler Italia is the right choice if these describe you:

• You make a litre or more of fizzy water each day. At that rate, the gas savings add up to thousands of rupees a year.
• Your soda maker can stay in one spot. It will live on your counter next to the mixer, and that is fine.
• You have a stockist nearby, or you are fine with mail-in refills. The refill route is what keeps this machine cheap.
• You want the lowest gas cost per litre. Cylinder gas beats capsules on price at every level of use.
• The whole family drinks fizzy water. At a litre a day, one cylinder of 20 to 25 litres lasts about three weeks.

If this sounds like you, Mr. Butler is probably the better buy. Recommending the wrong product helps nobody.

What Should You Know About Who Should Buy InstaCuppa?

Buy InstaCuppa if you want to try home soda without a big spend. It suits people who want fizz at work, on trips or now and then. It costs less to start, and the 10-day free trial lowers the risk. Check stock first, since it was sold out on 25 October 2026.

The InstaCuppa Portable Soda Maker is the right choice if these describe you:

• You want to try home soda with a small first spend. Rs 2,199 gets you the bottle, 2 lids and 10 capsules.
• You need fizz on the move. Think office, gym bag, trips or hostel rooms.
• You make a few litres a week. At 3 litres a week, capsules cost about Rs 100 a week on the 30-pack.
• You do not want to swap or courier gas cylinders. You just order capsules online.
• Your device budget is under Rs 2,500. The bottle costs about Rs 1,100 less than Mr. Butler's store price.

Which One Should You Buy? Our Honest Verdict

There is no single best soda maker, only the best fit for how you live. Mr. Butler wins on running cost, waste and fizz control. InstaCuppa wins on start-up price, size and simple capsule refills. Choose by how much soda you drink and where you drink it.

Say I were just a buyer, not the founder. I would ask two questions.

Do I make more than a litre of fizzy water at home every day? Is there a stockist near me, or am I fine with mail-in refills?

If yes to both, I would lean towards Mr. Butler. The gas savings are real at high use.

For everyone else, InstaCuppa makes more sense. That covers the now-and-then user, the office user and the buyer who wants a trial first.

Both are good products built for different people. Pick the one that matches how you will use it.

Still looking at other brands? See our best soda makers in India list or our soda maker for home buying guide.

Products Mentioned

Here are the three products this page compares. Our own two link to our store, and Mr. Butler links to its Amazon.in listing. We checked stock on 25 October 2026.

InstaCuppa Portable Soda Maker

Rs 2,199 with 10 capsules and 2 lids. Sold out on 25 October 2026.

Check Stock

InstaCuppa Soda Capsules (10, 20 or 30)

From Rs 499 for 10. Sold out on 25 October 2026.

Check Stock

Mr. Butler Italia Soda Maker (Single Cylinder Pack)

Rs 3,399 and in stock on Amazon.in on 25 October 2026. Machine, 1 cylinder and a 500 ml bottle in the box.

Check Price on Amazon

🔥 InstaCuppa Best Sellers

InstaCuppa Portable Blender for Smoothie and Juices, Milk ShShop NowInstaCuppa Premium Electric Chopper with 3 Unique AttachmentShop NowInstaCuppa Portable Blender with 4000 mAh Rechargeable BatteShop NowInstaCuppa Multipurpose Electric Kettle Cum Cooker with FreeShop NowInstaCuppa Insulated Water Bottle 1L — Stainless Steel ThermShop NowInstaCuppa Milk Frother for Coffee - Handheld Battery-OperatShop NowInstaCuppa Rechargeable Mini Electric Chopper, Chops In LessShop NowInstaCuppa Portable Multi Cook Electric Kettle with Non-SticShop NowInstaCuppa Automatic Curd Maker Machine | Probiotic-Rich YogShop NowInstaCuppa Automatic Water Dispenser for 20 Liter Cans with Shop NowInstaCuppa Portable Blender for Smoothie and Juices, Milk ShShop NowInstaCuppa Premium Electric Chopper with 3 Unique AttachmentShop NowInstaCuppa Portable Blender with 4000 mAh Rechargeable BatteShop NowInstaCuppa Multipurpose Electric Kettle Cum Cooker with FreeShop NowInstaCuppa Insulated Water Bottle 1L — Stainless Steel ThermShop NowInstaCuppa Milk Frother for Coffee - Handheld Battery-OperatShop NowInstaCuppa Rechargeable Mini Electric Chopper, Chops In LessShop NowInstaCuppa Portable Multi Cook Electric Kettle with Non-SticShop NowInstaCuppa Automatic Curd Maker Machine | Probiotic-Rich YogShop NowInstaCuppa Automatic Water Dispenser for 20 Liter Cans with Shop Now

Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through them we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only point to products we would suggest to our own family.